What brand? And, most importantly, which flavor? As if our ice cream decisions weren’t hard enough, Turkey Hill is adding seven new ice cream flavors to its already impressive line-up.

Cookie dough ice cream is hard to beat, no matter what form it comes in. However, after reviewing multiple brands, we found that one didn't quite make the cut.

Graeter's caramel flavor is more subtle. Steve's is tasty vanilla ice cream with salty, buttery caramel swirls, and it tastes freshly made. Turkey Hill is also vanilla with swirls, but it's ...