When artists rerelease their classic hits, the plan is usually pretty much the same: Remaster the recordings and release a cleaner, upscaled version of the album, maybe with an extra track or two.

Mary Brady was in the aisle of a Toys "R" Us near Miramar, Florida, when she felt a sharp, stabbing pain in her leg. She was one of dozens of adults crammed into the store in late 1986, all of them ...