"The primary evidence for probable cause is that DNA," Assistant Prosecutor Jerome Paul Neidhardt said. "DNA doesn't wear out. It doesn't lie." Robert McCaffrey's attorney claimed there was not enough ...
A North Carolina man is facing charges in one of Sussex County's most notorious cold cases, but how did authorities finally make an arrest after nearly 36 years? Robert William McCaffrey Jr., 54, was ...
Robert McCaffrey was arrested April 10 in the death of Lisa McBride, a Vernon woman whose body was found four months after she went missing in 1990. McCaffrey was charged with obstruction of justice ...