Luke also reveals whom he would have sent home had he beaten the Banker. Sometimes, while playing a game like Deal or No Deal Island, you can do everything right… and still lose. That’s simply what happens in a game of chance and luck.

There's no doubt Eagle River private chef Luke Olejniczak brought a taste of Wisconsin to the Season 2 premiere of "Deal or No Deal Island" Tuesday night.

The banker has claimed her first victim on Deal or No Deal Island Season 2. On Tuesday (January 7) night’s premiere, “The Banker Strikes Back,” the new crop of contestants were put to the test with a pyramid challenge called “The Bankers Pyramid Scheme.”

In just one episode, Luke Olejniczak established himself as a historic Deal or No Deal Island player, albeit for all the wrong reasons. Fortunately for reality TV fans, he’s not the only season 2 cast member who may go down in DONDI infamy.